Social Security Argument Over?

http://www.latimes.com/news/printedition/opinion/la-oe-kinsley19-proof,1,6663280.story

Most of us who have been paying attention have recognized the many deficiencies in the president's social security proposal, but only one person I know of has actually proved that the plan cannot work. The author of this proof is Michael Kinsley, editorial page editor of the Los Angeles Times. I've been pondering this rather simple piece of logic, and so far haven't been able to dent it, which makes me suspicious if for no other reason than I was predisposed to believe the conclusion. Also, of course, I didn't think of it first.

Please have a look at the link and see if it breaks down for you. Feel free to send it around.

DEMOPHOENIX